* * * * * * * * TERRIE'S (TOURISM) TAKE - BY TERRIE LLOYD * * * * * *
A bi-weekly focused look at the tourism sector in Japan, by Terrie
Lloyd, a long-term technology and media entrepreneur living in Japan.
Tourism Sector Edition Sunday, Mar 05, 2017, Issue No. 886
SUBSCRIBE to, UNSUBSCRIBE from Terrie's Take at:
+++ Japan's Online Travel Agency (OTA) Trends Over the Next 5-10 Years
Normally I keep my predictions to the first "Take" of the year, but
recently I have been involved in a number of proposals for large
regional clients and thus I'm spending a lot more time thinking about
strategy and industry trends. It is fair to say that in the Inbound
Travel sector, one of Japan's three distinct travel domains, the trends
are being set by foreign companies trying to bring global best practices
to Japan. In the hotel sector this is most clearly demonstrated by
Booking.com, which with almost 100 staff acquiring and onboarding local
hotels is so far ahead of its Japanese hotels OTA competitors in terms
of inventory, they may never catch up.
Indeed, not so long ago a senior manager at one major outbound OTA,
which also happens to be one of Booking.com's largest Outbound Travel
referral partners in Japan, told me that his company had already given
up on the idea of trying to establish itself in the Inbound sector.
Sure, they have a bilingual website, but in the face of such
overwhelming competition no one uses it.
To make a proposal for my clients, I need to have some basis on which to
project the business into the future - which means I have to make some
sense out of the chaotic state of Inbound travel to Japan. I base most
of my future assumptions on human behavioral models like Maslow's
Hierarchy of Needs - which readers will know is one of my favorites
(yes, with some adjustments). If you take the classic Maslow hierarchy,
of Physiological Needs, Safety, Love/belonging, Esteem, and Self
Actualization, and transpose it to a commercial model, you come out with
layers emphasizing Money/Price (the base layer of the Needs pyramid),
then Reliability/Convenience, Social/Peer Group, Brand/Status, and
finally Custom Services at the top.
In my 30 years in the IT-computer-software industry, whenever there has
been a major disruption in a commercial market, after the initial havoc
has been wreaked on the prevailing business model and everyone is
thinking straight again, Maslow's Needs come to the fore and allow
competitors to catch up to the innovator. As those competitors
re-marshal their forces, they tend to focus on cost competitiveness,
then product differentiation based on safety/convenience, and so on up
the ladder rungs of customer intellect.
A good example of this effect at work can be found in the smartphone
market. Apple initially disrupted the market by turning cell phones into
a personal entertainment device, and through its brilliant execution
they earned 5 years or so of being a sole seller, and making tons of
profit in the process. Customers were happy to pay top dollar because
they were buying at the Social/Peer group and Brand/Status levels.
However, now that just-as-good Android rivals have arrived, Apple's
position is quickly eroding as its competitors focus on Money/Price and
Reliability/Convenience. Unless Apple can come up with another hugely
disruptive business model, it is likely that the smartphone market will
enter a period of slow-climb differentiation following Maslow's principles.
I think that the travel sector, and particularly online travel, is
headed in a similar direction.
--------- From Veggie Burgers to Carrot Cake --------------
Our commitment at Alishan Organics is to give our customers the best of
western organic foods, but prepared with a Japanese twist. That's why
our menus cover such a broad range of styles and tastes. If you're just
getting to know us, why not visit our cafe by the river in Saitama? That
way you can try out a variety of dishes and decide for yourself. Choose
from an Amy's organic pizza straight from the oven, a mouthwatering
veggie burger packed with seasonal greens and reds, or if you're feeling
chilly, a filling vegetable curry with rice. And although we're healthy
minded, we don't skimp on desserts. Favorites include Jack's scrumptious
carrot cake, vegan brownies (of course with vegan ice cream), and baked
banana cheese cake.
Our Cafe: http://bit.ly/2m0r8z7
When Online Travel Agents (OTAs) first became popular a short 5 years
ago, their big selling points were: convenience, breadth of selection
within a narrow segment (for example, just hotels or just airfares), and
most importantly fellow user recommendations. But as the bigger players
(Expedia, Priceline/Booking.com, TripAdvisor, Airbnb, to name a few)
have grown, gained economies of scale, and have honed their software,
they are now slugging it out in a deeper differentiation battle.
Until now, the OTA wars have been about segment coverage, pricing, and
most recently real-time systems and instant services. But as I mentioned
in TT-885 several weeks ago, it's interesting to see that these same big
players are starting to evolve a "Phase 2" of the OTA business, which is
to become a global supermarket for everything to do with travel -
something like Amazon.com. This kind of ambition requires extreme levels
of investment in software, connectivity, and real time data systems,
that is far beyond anything that Japanese firms are capable of investing
in or building. OK, the two possible exceptions are Rakuten Travel and
Recruit (Jalan), who rather than build could simply apply their billions
to buy out major players abroad and thus leap-frog back into a viable
presence in their own national market.
It's what comes next, after breadth-of-services and low prices, that
will be most interesting. If I look at the e-commerce sector in general,
it's pretty clear that Artificial Intelligence (AI) is driving the
online discovery and purchasing experience and AI is just around the
corner for travel as well - although travel has infinitely more
variables and so is a lot more complex. I imagine that AI will be used
to provide customers with both recommendations for tours and actual tour
On the tours side, your itinerary will be built in real-time by machine
and which take into account hundreds of variables and preferences
including inferences drawn from your past online activities. On the tour
buddies side, the system will recommend and match you up with traveling
partners, just like a dating site, and places to stay that are
appropriate for your age and interests. In other words, the AI
experience will be something like an advanced Airbnb for the tours
(versus accommodation) industry.
But the real kicker is still a ways out yet. For all this software
wizardry, if you look at human behavior, then Maslow's triangle of needs
predicates that the top of the triangle won't be some automated function
(well, at least not until AI is as good as human thinking, and that's
not for a long while yet), but rather high-grade human-built content and
experiences that engage with our deepest urges for traveling - like a
drug for an emotional need.
Let's remember that the travel industry is similar to the movie
industry, in that its purpose is to supply a distraction of the
intellect through inspiration, dreams, thrills, curiosity, altruism, and
learning. Therefore, the quality of a customer's engagement experience
will determine their satisfaction and repeat use - and thus the level of
commercial success. I think that just like the movie industry, the
Japanese tourism industry will learn to graduate from just distribution
and simple transactions, to creating the actual Hollywood-grade content
that locks in their customers. In the world of online movies, Netflix
and most recently Amazon have realized this and now build and sell their
Therefore, at the top of Maslow's hierarchy of Needs in Travel, on top
of all that technology, I believe there will be a group of talented
individuals and investors creating unique and memorable holiday and
escape experiences that mere software functionality can't capture or
deliver. In a Japanese context I expect that entire destinations will be
transformed into immersive tourism experiences. Ski villages, historical
reenactment experiences, robotic experiences, food-cooking experiences,
religious experiences. They will be created like mini-Disneylands around
the country - or little WestWorlds without the messy robot problems.
This won't happen overnight, but already you can see examples of
"altered states" locations in Japan - such as the Niseko ski resort,
which has done amazingly well considering it is an artificially
implanted (i.e., mostly non-Japanese) construct. This is not intended as
a criticism btw. And for that matter, let's not forget the original
grand daddy of full-immersion holidays - Disneyworld. We don't have one
in Japan yet, but I'd not be surprised if a massive Disneyworld was on
the drawing board at Oriental Land right now. Kumamoto or Okinawa would
be a great locations to put it.
So in a nutshell, what are the trends for Japanese Inbound Tourism for
the next 5-10 years? In order of progression I believe them to be:
* Now - Basic web/mobile web content development and marketing.
* 2018-2021 - Real-time high-convenience IT systems to allow bored
foreign travel shoppers book and pay for a tour immediately. If you're
in IT, this will be a big new opportunity.
* Early-2020's - AI-assisted planning and/or curation of travel
experiences to best match the customer.
* Mid-2020's - Fully immersive experiences complete with actors and
absolute attention to detail.
If this trend to immersive experiences sounds familiar, that's because
we went through a similar cycle with Japanese domestic tourism and
entertainment back in the bubble years of the 1980's. Indeed, this is
when Huis Ten Bosch in Nagasaki, and all those converted or abandoned
countryside entertainment facilities came from... and so the wheel turns.
...The information janitors/
---------- ICA Event - Thursday 23rd March ----------------
Speaker: Thomas Nevins - Founder and Chief Consultant. TMT Inc
Title: "Doing Hard Labor in Japan"
Details: Complete event details at http://www.icajapan.jp/
Date: Thursday 23rd March, 2017
Time: 6:30pm Doors open
Cost: 1,000 yen (members), 2,000 yen (non-members). Open to all. No sign
ups at the door!!!!!!!
RSVP: By 5pm on Monday 20th March 2017
Venue: Room F, 9F, Sumitomo Fudosan Roppongi Grand Tower, 3-2-1
Roppongi, Minato-ku, Tokyo, 106-0032
SUBSCRIBERS: 6,524 members as of Mar 05, 2017 (We purge our list regularly.)
+++ ABOUT US
Written by: Terrie Lloyd (firstname.lastname@example.org)
HELP: E-mail Terrieemail@example.com with the word 'help' in
the subject or body (don't include the quotes), and you will get back a
message with instructions.
Send letters (Feedback, Inquiries & Information) to the editor to
For more information on advertising in this newsletter, contact
Get Terrie's Take by giving your name and email address at
http://www.japaninc.com/newsletters/free_sign_up, or go straight to
Copyright 2017 Japan Inc. Communications Inc.
----------------- Japan Inc opens up Japan ----------------
J@pan Inc authoritatively chronicles business trends in Japan. Each
posting brings you in-depth analysis of business, people and technology
in the world's third largest economy.
Visit www.japaninc.com for the best business insight on Japan available.
Terrie mailing list