Anna Kitanaka Anna Kitanaka
about the author

"Ground breaking smoking ban for Japan"

Kanagawa prefecture have announced plans for a ‘Public Facilities No Smoking Regulation’. This regulation is already active in hospitals and schools but now there are plans to expand its reach to Pachinko parlors and Izakayas.

Display a printer-friendly version of this page.print
Print this article.email
RSS feed for all J@pan Inc blogs.RSS
Author's blogs
J@pan Inc blogs

If this rule comes into force, it will be Japan’s first groundbreaking anti-smoking legislation.
Restaurants and shops serving food and drink are voicing concerns that this will negatively affect their sales. The medical establishment, who are a driving force behind anti-smoking measures, are giving their approval to this new regulation. In Kanagawa, this issue is already causing friction.

The Mainichi Shimbun reports some differing local opinions.

Against:

1. Ryoji Shiraishi, the owner of four pachinko parlors in Yokohama and is against the regulations due to concerns about sales says: “Over 70% of my customers smoke.”

2. Noriko Ebina, the Head of the Secretariat for Yokohama’s ‘Food and Drink Business Livelihood Health and Hygiene Trade Association’ (literal translation) says: “I feel we are being bullied. We have already been affected by the tightening of the Drink Driving Road Traffic Act…”

3. The public relations department for JT tobacco says, “Coffee shops, pachinko parlors and hotels have a different clientele so we are against a broad ban. It should be left up to each business owner to decide for themselves.”

For:

1. Yoshihito Fujiwara, the Director for Yokohama’s pediatricians’ ‘Anti-smoking Kanagawa Assembly for the Propulsion of Separate Smoking Areas’ says “these penal regulations are natural. Passive smoking has gone beyond being just annoying, it is a health affecting assault. There are limits to just suing people for breaching manners.”

2. Manabu Sakuda, the Board Chairman for the ‘Anti-smoking Scientific Society of Japan’ says “these rules that are thought of as groundbreaking in Japan yet are normal in other countries abroad.”

The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare reported that in 2005 Japan had roughly 30.2 million smokers—around 25% of the population (see JIN: http://www.japaninc.com/jin422.

With countries such as the UK and Australia already imposing anti-smoking measures in public places and places serving food and drink, it seems only natural that Japan would be next in following in the footsteps of a global ban on smoking. However, as mentioned in JIN 422 (Smoke on the horizon: http://www.japaninc.com/jin422), the perception of smoking may be quite different from those in other countries. Although underage smoking is harshly frowned upon (and made harder recently with the new age identification measure for cigarette vending machines), and smoking whilst walking for a lady is thought of as very taboo, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare reported that in 2005 Japan had roughly 30.2 million smokers—that’s around 25%of the population who still smoke.

However, with smoking banned on many streets throughout the country, new smoking bans in taxis and regulation tightening for under-age smoking , it seems only natural that the next step for Japan would be to start banning it in public places…


Oh, no -- please do not ban

Oh, no -- please do not ban smoking in pachiko parlors and izakaya! The smoking is precisely what discourages good people from venturing into those establishments! If pachinko parlors and izakaya become zones of healthful fun, where will the sorry low self-esteem types go to hang out? ;-)

Smoking Ban

How on earth can someone say let the smoke continue killing innocent non-smokers!!! Why is the rest of the world banning smoke in all places like UK, California and even Hong Kong!

Very sad that Japan with all

Very sad that Japan with all its "greatness" is so stupid not to understand or realize the damage smokers are doing to themselves and to non-smokers.
Very selfish. Second hand smoke is dreadful.

Wake up Japan and think of others' health as well as your own.

BAN smoking in all public restaurants, bars and indoor places like civilized countries do and let the smokers puff outdoors!

This is.. not right.

Yes, smoking is damaging to others but if others don't want to be around it, they dont have to go there. If they don't want to be around people smoking, they can simply go somewhere in which there is no smoking. It really is not brain surgery. I do not smoke, nor will I ever, as it is a nasty habit in my opinion.

The owner of the business should have the right to decide for themselves whether or not smoking should be aloud in their business. Governments are authoritarian enough as it is. It would be violating the rights of the business owner by doing this. Many businesses find good business in smoking sections as it has been mentioned. Governments should only be able to ban smoking in government owned facilities, otherwise its simply impeding the rights of the business owner. I actually applaud Japan for being one of the few countries left to not have government regulated smoking bans.

I have seen many japanese

I have seen many japanese parents smoke when small kids are around. I have even seen people smoke in cars with all windows closed and with children sitting inside. In Japan, people are not aware of ill effects of even passive smoking....it should be taught in the school level.

The risks of passive smoking are exaggerated

I love holidaying in Japan, and one of the things I love about Japan is that they haven't bought into the passive smoking propoganda. Read the studies pasive smoking is based on and you will see that the dangers are over exaggerated.

It would be sad if business owners in this great country lose their freedom of choice and Japan becomes a nanny state like Australia has become.

There are plenty of people

There are plenty of people that play pachinko and are still good people.

smoking ban is a good idea

The government banned smoking in public places because it stops people smoking, will make people healthier, live longer and stop many diseases.
The dangers of smoking are causes different kind of cancers such as mouth cancer, throat, tongue and lung cancer. It also causes heart disease, halitosis, yellow teeth, gum disease, smells of cigarettes. It also causes bronchitis and passive smoking.
Passive smoking is second hand smoke; it’s when you breathe in when people are smoking and you suffer from it as it can give you cancer and other diseases. Most people want to ban smoking because of passive smoking, it is dangerous because it causes a lot of deaths, as it is second hand smoking innocent people die and they don’t even smoke. Also many people believe this will make smokers quit smoking as the ban will encourage more smokers to quit because they can’t get cigarettes as much as they used to and people have a right to protect themselves from smoke inhalation. Smoking also damages the environment and causes different types of cancers and diseases.
Smoking ban is a serious issue as it causes lots deaths; I believe that the public should be discussing this matter.
The current pack of 20 cigarettes is for £5.66 and 77% of the money goes to tax which is £4.33 goes to the government because that is currently the tax the government charges for cigarettes, this is why maybe the government only introduced a smoking ban in public places, e.g. pubs. The government benefits from the cigarettes sold in the UK so that is why they have not introduced a full smoking ban in the UK. u get ripped of for a packed of ciggarite and also y do innocent people have to die coz of smokers.it costs all lot of monet to do opration, if they ban smoking they will save money on these kind of things

The usual passive smoking lies

Passive smoking is a made up disease. I have never met any anti-smoker who actually knows anybody who has died from passive smoking. If it was so widespread and dangerous you would think somebody knows someone who has died from it. I know people who have died from road accidents but passive smoking...impossible to find.

All the anti-smokers keep talking about the the thousands that die from passive smoking, but they never know anyone who has. Meanwhile these anti-smokers pump vast amounts of cancerous pollutants from their motor vehicles into the air, killing their children and giving them asthma.

If all smokers stopped smoking tomorrow, governments would be bankrupt within 20 years. Smoke or not smoke, you still need medical attention. If you live longer you need lots of medical attention in your old age and vast amounts of social housing and care. The costs of these will break the tax payer.

Signed by Dr Marlboro

I assume above comment was submitted by Dr Marlboro disguised as Stevo.

Passive smoking is not a disease

Most uneducated, uninformed comment EVER. Passive smoking is not a disease, but causes and leads to disease. Suck in enough 2nd hand smoke, and you too can start developing cancer. Plenty of people die from lung cancer who don't smoke, and we will not know if 2nd hand smoke contributes to that, or the myriad of other diseases (since 2nd hand smoke contains hundreds of deadly chemicals).

2nd hand smoke and it's dangers have been well documented and studied by the well recognized medical journals. If smokers and tobacco companies choose to ignore that - and spread their counter-propaganda - than that's their problem. Smokers will continue to ignore the health of those around them and society in defense of their addiction and under the guise of "personal freedom".

Hmm, speaking of uneducated and uninformed

The fact is that smoking does not CAUSE cancer. Even for a life long 20-a-day person. Smoking is a risk factor in the development of cancer, specifically lung cancer.
Second hand smoke has never even been proven to be a significant risk factor in the development of cancer. Carcinogens emitted by vehicle exhausts are considerably more likely to contribute more to the risk of someone developing cancer than 2nd hand smoke. Perhaps you would like to ban cars?

Coming from the UK, where there is a smoking ban in pubs and restaurants, it is tragic to see the decline in business, community and atmosphere that this has led to in my local pubs - last time I went home it was so noticeable.
Evan as a smoker I will admit that smoke free restaurants, especially where tables are close together, isn't such a bad thing, for non-smokers in particular.

As so many others have said leave it up to the bar or restaurant proprieter to make their own rules but please don't try and advocate a blanket ban based upon your own 'understanding' of faux-science.

"The fact is that smoking

"The fact is that smoking does not CAUSE cancer"

HAHAAAA what a moron. I hope this person keeps thinking this way so they die of cancer and rid the world of their stupidity.

It's an extremely important

It's an extremely important decision especially for the passive smokers, inhale the smoke of the cigarette without any cause. It is a first major step towards the saving of the live of the numerous people, who come under this devilish smoke. It should be ban in the films as well. In cinems, action movies,Poker Movies, having casino scenes, promote smoking majorly. People idolize the characters and try to smoke like them.
It leaves an adverse effect on the society.

please explain...

Please explain why lung cancer rates in Japan are soooo much lower than those in USA, although japanese are much heavier smokers.
Second-hand smoking has been for many years an excuse used by governments that refuse to deal with pollution issues and many others, much more expensive to take care of.
Even fireplaces are more dangerous than second-hand smoking.

Brainwashed

Like most other issues that are pushed under the covers here, the only reason the rates of smoking related disease is lower is because the media is being paid off by JT. Hence, they are not as quick to blame smoking as their foriegn counterparts, which already have the support of the government. On the otherhand, the Japanese government actively promotes smoking by members of the diet smoking on TV, jokes about smoking not causing cancer etc etc.
So once you get over being brainwashed by the joke that is called an "independent media" here, then we can have a real debate about the harmful effects of smoking. Personally, I think the lack of education related to smoking here is shameful, and Japan does not deserve to be called a "senshinkoku" in this regard. Parent's that smoke around their children don't deserve to be called parents.

japan smoking paradox

The main factors likely to have brought about the difference in the odds ratio/relative risk between Japan and the USA (and perhaps other Western countries as well) are: Earlier age of smoking onset in Americans, lower alcohol consumption by Japanese males; lower fat intake by Japanese males; higher efficiency of filters on Japanese cigarettes; lower levels of carcinogenic ingredients in Japanese cigarettes; and lung-cancer-resistant hereditary factors among Japanese males.

smoking ban

I suggest that as a form of protest coming from all the smokers in Japan, they should all buy cigars and fog their government. Imagine 5000 to 10 000 thousand people smoking cigars at the same time.

Ban smoking on all streets in Japan

I dont know about the level of health hazards caused by passive smoking but i would like to urge the policy makers to put a ban on street smoking across all over Tokyo.

Almost everyday when i leave my home on the way to office, i am hit by the passive smoke of a passerby. This is the worst part of staying in Tokyo. I have kind of an allergy to smoke and it irritates my eyes, nose and the smell remains on my clothes sometimes even until i reach the office. I think many non-smokers too face a similar trouble. Please put an end to our misery !

The lung cancer percentage

The lung cancer percentage here in japan is extremely high! I think, if i remember correctly that lung cancer has the highest occurrence of any form of cancer!

Stinky...?

Health risks aside, it always amazes me that smokers don't appear to care what they smell like. I mean, really, their breath stinks. I suppose they just can't smell it themselves.

Japan after all

I used to leave in Japan a while back. As far as the anti-smoking movement is going, it started in the USA and then spread to Europe. I remember when I moved to New York from Paris in 1989. I was smoking in the elevator and people complained. This had never happened to me before in France.
Europe is still behind, for instance you can smoke in the subway. But they are catching up fast. Now Asia is way way behind, I mean WAY behind. Japan is leading the way and this is good news. When I lived there I was a smoker and I do not remember ever been asked to stopped my smoking anywhere.

remember the entry of Starbucks to Japan?

I can't wait to see wider adoption of non-smoking places. If you asked somebody in Japan 10 years ago, if they thought that a non-smoking coffee shop could become THE premium coffee shop chain in the country, they would have laughed it off as a joke. Starbucks proved them wrong. The lesson to be learned is that these shops can still benefit by adapting to the changes that are happening globally. They have plenty of examples to draw from overseas so they really have no excuse other than they are afraid to change and learn to adapt their business models.

I really hope it goes through. Makes Yokohama look even more attractive to me and my business from a lifestyle point of view. Imagine a country as wonderful as Japan where it's no longer a challenge to find a decent place to have a smoke free pint after hours.

smoking in the workplace

My employer still allows smoking in their office. Not at the desk, but in the hallway. The smoke drifts through the open door and into the desk area. This doesn't really doesn't give me the choice of whether to be in that environment or not.

Are their any labour laws, helpful resources, etc. to assist me in encouraging the shacho to take a stand an ban smoking in the building outright?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may post code using <code>...</code> (generic) or <?php ... ?> (highlighted PHP) tags.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Syndicate content